FAN ex German Cruisers (CL-1917-18)
Back to French Navy page
With the signing of the Armistice, the whole of France gave a huge sigh of
relief. It was left to each of the arms of the armed forces to look at what it
had and what it was going to need the most urgent. The French, looking at the
Fleet, knew exactly what it needed. Modern ships of all classes. The latest
Bretagne class battleships were a generation behind the latest British, German,
US, and Japanese ships. The newest ships being built at 45-50,000 tons staggered
the French Navy. It had no money to try and build even one of those huge
monsters. Thankfully for France the Washington Treaty stepped in and those
monsters disappeared, for now. Looking at its cruiser stocks they were worse off
than the battleships. Their most modern cruisers were the three old Ernest Renan
type armoured cruisers of 1911. The only way to improve this was to get as many
of the modern, war built, surrendered German ships. They would fill a gap until
the French building industries could catch up. The War Reparations Committee
that was overseeing the dispersal of the surrendered ships was made aware of the
French shopping list. With the agreement of Britain and the US, the French were
allowed to nominate the German ships they would need. This included four capital
ships, six cruisers and a dozen destroyers. Other miscellaneous ships, such as
minesweepers, were also sourced. Along with the completed ships, the
German building yards had may ships under construction and nearing completion.
Two extra Dresden II class uncompleted ships were towed to French yards for
completion. These eight German cruisers would fill the French Fleet for the next
fifteen years. The French may have looked down on them but they were still first
class ships. When the French started looking at upgrading its medium sized
weapons, the Royal Navy experts pointed to the 5.9" guns on the cruisers and
said copying the breech blocks from those would give a good weapon.
The French ended up with two Magdeburg class ships with 7x5.9", two Konigsberg
II class with 8x5.9", and two completed Dresden II class with 8x5.9. A further
two uncompleted Dresden II class made up its allocation of German cruisers. The
French figured they would only need to serve for a minimum of 10 years while
their replacements were being built. In the end, only the two Magdeburg class
did not make it to World War Two, being discarded and scrapped in 1938. The
other six had had various levels of refits and rebuilding that took them into
WW2
These first three drawings represent a pair of cruisers each, in the
configuration they would have arrived in French waters, joining the French
Fleet. In real life the French made very few improvements to the ships. A
few light AA guns and that was it. With my having the Japanese abrogating the London Treaty in 1930,
these ships are going to get a reprieve and like a lot of old cruisers, kept in
service longer than they might have otherwise done. Both pairs of Koln and
Konigsberg class ships were taken in hand from 1936 to refit them as escort
cruisers. This removed all of the 5.9" which was good for the French as it was
one less size of shell needing to be kept in the inventory. These were replaced
with four twin 3.9" mounted fore and aft as above. The torpedoes were kept. The
other minor weapons were removed and replaced with twin 37mm and 20mm
Hispano-Suiza cannons. One of the priorities for the French Navy was to guard
the transfer of the French North African Army to mainland France. These ships
were earmarked for that job. On completion of that task two of the ships were
transferred to Fort de France to become AA escorts for the Bearn. The other two
were held at Mers-el-Kebir as AA escorts for the Commandante Teste.
The next drawing in the series has to be the uncompleted Koln II class ships and
what the French did to them for French service. The ships were in an incomplete
state. No armament or superstructure had been fitted. The machinery had been
installed but never run. All the decks were in place.
The ships design still had more than half of the armament mounted on the
broadside. So their eight gun broadside could actually only fire five guns to
either side. This is on a 5,600 ton cruiser. The equivalent British 'C' class
had the same 5 gun broadside but on a 4,400 ton cruiser. Definitely a win to the
British. The two ships swung around their buoys in Brest Harbour while plans
were made as to what could be done to the ships to improve them. The French were
also planning the Duguay Trouin class of three six inch cruisers, and it was
decided that with a bit of rejigging of the internals a main armament of 3 twin
turrets of the Duguay Trouin type could be mounted on the hulls. The rest of the
armament was six 75mm AA guns, further AA machine guns and cannons were added in
the late 1920's and 1930's.
The Saint Nazaire received its major refit in 1940 and had just left the
builders yard in Brest, bound for Fort de France, when the armistice was called.
The ship had its orders and kept going. Joining the Bearn and other units in
self internment at Fort de France. Sistership Calais was in the Mediterranean
and due to go to Toulon for its major refit, but this was cancelled and the ship
ordered to join the Fleet at Mers-el-Kebir. What happens to them post 'Torch' in
1942 is yet to be written.
Displacement | Magdeburg Class 4,600 tons normal,
5,600 tons full load Konigsberg II Class 5,450 tons normal, 7,150 tons full load Koln II Class 5,600 tons normal, 7,500 tons full load |
|||||
Length | Magdeburg 455 ft, Konigsberg II 497 ft, Koln II 510 ft | |||||
Breadth | Magdeburg 44 ft, Konigsberg II 47 ft, Koln II 47 ft | |||||
Draught | Magdeburg 14 ft, Konigsberg II 20 ft, Koln II 20 ft | |||||
Machinery | Magdeburg, 2 shaft steam turbines, 25,000shp, Konigsberg II 31,000shp, Koln II 31,000shp | |||||
Speed | 28 knots | |||||
Range | Magdeburg, 6000 miles at 12 knots, Konigsberg II 5,000 miles at 12 knots, Koln II 5.500 miles at 12 knots | |||||
Armour | 2.5" side, 1.5" deck | |||||
Armament | Magdeburg (as received) 7 x 5.9" (7x1) 2 x 3.4" (2x1) |
Konigsberg II (as received) 8 x 5.9" (8x1) 3 x 3.4" (3x1)
|
Koln II (as received) 8 x 5.9" (8x1) 3 x 3.4" (3x1) |
Konigsberg II and Koln II (1940) 8 x 3.9" (4x2) 8 x 37mm (4x2) 8 x 20mm (8x1) |
Dresden II as rebuilt 1925 6 x 6.1" (3x2) 6 x 75mm (6x1) 4 x 25mm (4x1) |
Dresden II refits to 1940 6 x 6.1" (3x2) 10 x 3.9" (5x2) 8 x 37mm (4x2) 8 x 20mm H-S (8x1) |
Torpedoes | 2 x 19.7" (2x1) | 4 x 19.7" (2x2) | 8 x 19.7" (4x2) | 4 or 8 x 21" (2/4x2) | 8 x 21" (4x2) | 4 x 21" (2x2) |
Complement | 390 | 475 | 560 | 580 | 600 | 625 |
Notes | FAN Mullhouse FAN Saint Nazaire |
Note: the German 19.7" torpedoes were swapped out for French 21".